Peer Review Done Differently

We began to engage patients and other stakeholders in our peer-review process in 2016, with a workshop at a conference on patient-focused healthcare issues. We tested reviewer materials to be sure that patients found them useful and clear, and that the patients’ work would meaningfully complement traditional scientific review. Our team then developed and refined online training materials for patient reviewers and outlines of questions that patients were best equipped to answer.

During PCORI’s 2017 Annual Meeting, we hosted another workshop for patient peer reviewers, in which we gathered feedback on the process, heard how their efforts have affected the way awardees’ final research reports summarize their projects and results, and brainstormed how to improve on emerging best practices. (See box below, Gaining a Seat at the Table) In the next year, we will be exploring improvements to peer review to benefit patient reviewers, including the opportunity to serve on an editorial board for peer review, and establishing a buddy system so that experienced reviewers can mentor new reviewers.

PCORI’s mission to incorporate patients throughout the research process is evident in the inclusion of several types of patient representatives—those with lived experience, caregivers, family members, and advocates from organizations that represent a disease or specific population. Peer review is no different.

Want to Have an Impact? Become a Patient Peer Reviewer

PCORI is constantly seeking patients and other healthcare stakeholders with experiences and expertise to help us do a better job of assessing the importance of the studies we fund. Capturing the insights of a diverse group of patients is vital to providing a more holistic picture of healthcare choices.

PCORI encourages patients, family caregivers, and representatives of health-focused communities to apply to serve as PCORI peer reviewers. We’ll provide training and ongoing assistance to reviewers. For more information and to apply to become a PCORI peer reviewer, please visit our website. We look forward to welcoming more people to the growing community of patients and other stakeholders helping to support PCORI’s efforts to advance research done differently.

The views expressed here are those of the authors and not necessarily those of PCORI.