Skip to main content
Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute
Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute
  • Blog
  • Newsroom
  • Find It Fast
  • Help Center
  • Subscribe
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

PCORI

Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute

Search form

  • About Us
    Close mega-menu

    About Us

    • Our Programs
    • Governance
    • Financials and Reports
    • Procurement Opportunities
    • Our Staff
    • Our Vision & Mission
    • Contact Us

    Fact Sheets: Learn More About PCORI

    Download fact sheets about out work, the research we fund, and our programs and initiatives.

    Find It Fast

    Browse through an alphabetical list of frequently accessed and searched terms for information and resources.

    Subscribe to PCORI Email Alerts

    Sign up for weekly emails to stay current on the latest results of our funded projects, and more.

  • Research & Results
    Close mega-menu

    Research & Results

    • Explore Our Portfolio
    • Evaluating Our Work
    • Research Results Highlights
    • Putting Evidence to Work
    • Peer Review
    • Evidence Synthesis
    • About Our Research

    Evidence Updates from PCORI-Funded Studies

    These updates capture highlights of findings from systematic reviews and our funded research studies.

    Journal Articles About Our Funded Research

    Browse through a collection of journal publications that provides insights into PCORI-funded work.

    Explore Our Portfolio of Funded Projects

    Find out about projects based on the health conditions they focus on, the state they are in, and if they have results.

  • Topics
    Close mega-menu

    Topics

    • Addressing Disparities
    • Arthritis
    • Asthma
    • Cancer
    • Cardiovascular Disease
    • Children's Health
    • Community Health Workers
    • COVID-19
    • Dementia and Cognitive Impairment
    • Diabetes
    • Intellectual and/or Developmental Disabilities
    • Kidney Disease
    • Maternal Morbidity and Mortality
    • Medicaid
    • Men's Health
    • Mental and Behavioral Health
    • Minority Mental Health
    • Multiple Chronic Conditions
    • Multiple Sclerosis
    • Obesity
    • Older Adults' Health
    • Pain Care and Opioids
    • Rare Diseases
    • Rural Health
    • Shared Decision Making
    • Telehealth
    • Transitional Care
    • Veterans Health
    • Women's Health

    Featured Topic: Women's Health

    Learn more about the projects we support on conditions that specifically or more often affect women.

  • Engagement
    Close mega-menu

    Engagement

    • The Value of Engagement
    • Engagement in Health Research Literature Explorer
    • Influencing the Culture of Research
    • Engagement Awards
    • Engagement Resources
    • Engage with Us

    Engagement Tools and Resources for Research

    This searchable peer-to-peer repository includes resources that can inform future work in patient-centered outcomes research.

    Engagement Awards

    Learn about our Engagement Awards program and view the announcements of all our open funding opportunities.

    Research Fundamentals: A New On-Demand Training

    It enables those new to health research or patient-centered research to learn more about the research process.

  • Funding Opportunities
    Close mega-menu

    Funding Opportunities

    • What & Who We Fund
    • What You Need to Know to Apply
    • Applicant Training
    • Merit Review
    • Awardee Resources
    • Help Center

    PCORI Funding Opportunities

    View and learn about the newly opened funding announcements and the upcoming PFAs in 2021.

    Tips for Submitting a Responsive LOI

    Find out what PCORI looks for in a letter of intent (LOI) along with other helpful tips.

    PCORI Awardee Resources

    These resources can help awardees in complying with the terms and conditions of their contract.

  • Meetings & Events
    Close mega-menu

    Meetings & Events

    • Upcoming
    • Past Events

    PCORI 2021 and Beyond

    During this webinar, PCORI leaders shared ways to get involved in PCOR, improvements to our funding opportunities, and more.

    2020 PCORI Annual Meeting

    Watch recordings of sessions and view titles and descriptions of posters presented at the virtual meeting.

    Board Approves Future PFA Topics at April Meeting

    The more than a dozen high-priority research topics will be considered for PCORI Funding Announcements (PFAs) that will be released this fall and in 2022.

You are here

  • Blog
  • Patients Become Partners in PCORI Pee...

Patients Become Partners in PCORI Peer Review

Date: 
February 1, 2018
Blog Topics: 
Dissemination,
Guest Blogs,
Peer Review Blogs,
Research

Peer review—independent assessment by recognized experts—is central to the research process, from deciding which study proposals to fund to evaluating articles for publication in scientific journals. At PCORI, our authorizing law requires the completed research we fund to undergo peer review, which ensures scientific integrity and adherence to our methodology standards.

But as we developed our peer-review process in 2015, we decided it should do more, incorporating our patient-centered approach to research while maintaining the principles of a time-honored scientific process. Traditionally, all peer reviewers are scientific content experts. But we added patients and other healthcare stakeholders as reviewers. The idea is that, along with asking scientists about the studies, we consult others with practical expertise and lived experience about the relevance, usefulness, and patient-centeredness of the studies.

To realize this goal, our partners at Oregon Health and Science University (including two of this blog’s coauthors), which helps manage the PCORI peer-review process, identified and trained a cadre of patients and other stakeholder reviewers. These reviewers assess completed PCORI-funded studies by analyzing the draft final research reports that PCORI’s awardees submit when they finish their projects.

More than 400 patients and other stakeholders have signed up to be PCORI peer reviewers. 50 percent are patients. 30 percent are patient advocates. 20 percent are caregivers. 100 have already completed a peer review.

Peer Review Done Differently

We began to engage patients and other stakeholders in our peer-review process in 2016, with a workshop at a conference on patient-focused healthcare issues. We tested reviewer materials to be sure that patients found them useful and clear, and that the patients’ work would meaningfully complement traditional scientific review. Our team then developed and refined online training materials for patient reviewers and outlines of questions that patients were best equipped to answer.

During PCORI’s 2017 Annual Meeting, we hosted another workshop for patient peer reviewers, in which we gathered feedback on the process, heard how their efforts have affected the way awardees’ final research reports summarize their projects and results, and brainstormed how to improve on emerging best practices. (See box below, Gaining a Seat at the Table) In the next year, we will be exploring improvements to peer review to benefit patient reviewers, including the opportunity to serve on an editorial board for peer review, and establishing a buddy system so that experienced reviewers can mentor new reviewers.

PCORI’s mission to incorporate patients throughout the research process is evident in the inclusion of several types of patient representatives—those with lived experience, caregivers, family members, and advocates from organizations that represent a disease or specific population. Peer review is no different.

A group of attendees at a PCORI meeting.

Patients and caregivers who participate in PCORI peer review attend a workshop on peer review at the 2017 PCORI Annual Meeting.

Want to Have an Impact? Become a Patient Peer Reviewer

PCORI is constantly seeking patients and other healthcare stakeholders with experiences and expertise to help us do a better job of assessing the importance of the studies we fund. Capturing the insights of a diverse group of patients is vital to providing a more holistic picture of healthcare choices.

PCORI encourages patients, family caregivers, and representatives of health-focused communities to apply to serve as PCORI peer reviewers. We’ll provide training and ongoing assistance to reviewers. For more information and to apply to become a PCORI peer reviewer, please visit our website. We look forward to welcoming more people to the growing community of patients and other stakeholders helping to support PCORI’s efforts to advance research done differently.

PCORI has offered a way for caregivers, including siblings like myself, to have a seat at the table.

Eunice Im
Gaining a Seat at the Table
Eunice Im is an administrator for a cardiology clinic, cofounder of the California Sibling Leadership Network, a caregiver for a sibling with autism, and a PCORI peer reviewer.
Headshot of Eunice Im

I was initially drawn to PCORI’s peer-review process because a member of my family has autism, and I have often served as a caregiver. That experience exposed me to the need for more patient-centered health care. Had my family known more about shared decision making and had easier access to information about evidence-based treatments for autism, my family could have been better engaged, which would have alleviated some of our emotional and spiritual distress.

So far, being a peer reviewer has been a constructive way for me to contribute toward creating a better healthcare system. I found the PCORI workshop I attended in 2017 very valuable in generating ideas that will lead to meaningful improvements in PCORI’s peer-review process. I left with a better idea of how to more skillfully contribute to the review process.

Being a part of PCORI's peer-review process has been a fulfilling experience. Siblings of people with disabilities and other chronic conditions are traditionally overlooked in health care. But over the course of their lifetime, siblings gather a wealth of knowledge and wisdom regarding what their brothers and sisters are experiencing. 

Family members of people with chronic conditions can be critical partners in deciding how to best care for those we love and playing a role in shaping the research that will make that care more effective and patient centered. We are an untapped resource. PCORI has offered a way for caregivers, including siblings like myself, to have a seat at the table. (Back to top)


The views expressed here are those of the authors and not necessarily those of PCORI.

Comments

I suggest that you use the

Ronald Frank February 1, 2018 11:13 pm

Permalink

I suggest that you use the complete name PCORI
(Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute) at least once in each article. Strive for clarity. Avoid repetitive use of certain words if they can be expressed in different terms.

  • reply

Hi Ronald, thank you very

PCORI February 5, 2018 1:42 pm

Permalink

Hi Ronald, thank you very much for your comment. It has been shared with our editorial team.

  • reply

Patients reviewers are

Sandra Finestone February 15, 2018 5:59 pm

Permalink

Patients reviewers are currently used within most of the research funding vehicles. They have proven to be able to provide invaluable insight within the review and even in the writing of the applications themselves. In todays research environment, not having a patient reviewer has the potential to lessen both the effectiveness and the impact of the application

  • reply

Hi Sandra, we appreciate your

PCORI February 21, 2018 9:30 am

Permalink

Hi Sandra, we appreciate your comment. Thanks so much.

  • reply

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about text formats

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Author(s): 

Marina Broitman, PhD

Associate Director, Peer Review
Peer Review

Kira Lesley

Project Assistant, Oregon Health and Science University

Whitney Brower, MPH

Rebekah Webb, MPA

Project Coordinator, Oregon Health and Science University

Topics

Dissemination
Guest Blogs
Peer Review Blogs
Research

About Us

  • Our Programs
  • Governance
  • Financials and Reports
  • Procurement Opportunities
  • Our Staff
  • Our Vision & Mission
  • Contact Us

Research & Results

  • Explore Our Portfolio
  • Evaluating Our Work
  • Research Results Highlights
  • Putting Evidence to Work
  • Peer Review
  • Evidence Synthesis
  • About Our Research

Engagement

  • The Value of Engagement
  • Engagement in Health Research Literature Explorer
  • Influencing the Culture of Research
  • Engagement Awards
  • Engagement Resources
  • Engage with Us

Funding Opportunities

  • What & Who We Fund
  • What You Need to Know to Apply
  • Applicant Training
  • Merit Review
  • Awardee Resources
  • Help Center

Meetings & Events

April 27
Priorities on the Health Horizon: Informing PCORI's Strategic Plan (Webinar #2)
May 6
Advisory Panel on Healthcare Delivery and Disparities Research Spring 2021 Meeting
May 10
Cycle 2 2021 Nonsurgical Options for Women with Urinary Incontinence -- Applicant Town Hall

PCORI

Footer contact address

Patient-Centered Outcomes
Research Institute

1828 L Street, NW, Suite 900
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: (202) 827-7700 | Fax: (202) 355-9558
info@pcori.org

Subscribe to Newsletter

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Vimeo

© 2011-2021 Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Trademark Usage Guidelines | Credits | Help Center